USA vs. Al-Arian (2007)
Abdullah Al-Arian, George W. Bush, Laila Al-Arian
Sami Al-Arian has worked for many years as a dedicated activist and lobbyist for the Palestinian cause in the USA. In 2003 he was arrested and jailed, accused by American authorities of having given economic support to Palestinian terrorist groups. In spite of many years of investigation, hearings, ... (read more) Sami Al-Arian has worked for many years as a dedicated activist and lobbyist for the Palestinian cause in the USA. In 2003 he was arrested and jailed, accused by American authorities of having given economic support to Palestinian terrorist groups. In spite of many years of investigation, hearings, and a six-month long, high profile court case with over 80 witnesses, the authorities were unable to convince a jury that Al-Arian was guilty. But this verdict did not make a difference--Al-Arian is still in jail. The documentary allows the audience to follow the case against Al-Arian through the eyes of his wife and children, and shows the consequences of the USA's controversial Patriot Act--a law that was promoted as a necessary step in the war against terror--and which has led to loss of freedom, betrayal of civil rights, and political persecution.
Flixster Users
Unrated, 1 hr. 40 min.
Directed by:
Line Halvorsen
Release Date: Feb 23, 2007
Your Rating
Your Friends' Ratings
No recent reviews.
Flixster User Reviews
Haven't seen, but found this about it: "It's a disturbing film on freedom of speech in post 9/11 America and political persecution. The film follows the arrest and trial of Sami Al-Arian, an Arab-American university professor accused of supporting a ... (read more) Haven't seen, but found this about it: "It's a disturbing film on freedom of speech in post 9/11 America and political persecution. The film follows the arrest and trial of Sami Al-Arian, an Arab-American university professor accused of supporting a terrorist organization abroad. For two and a half years Dr. Al-Arian was held in solitary confinement, denied basic privileges and given limited access to his attorneys."
Kafka has nothing on this. A family's home gets raided, the head of the household arrested, and thrown into solitary confinement for two years for nothing that he has done. Imprisoned without trial when the victim, Dr. Sami al-Arian, is finally taken... (read more) Kafka has nothing on this. A family's home gets raided, the head of the household arrested, and thrown into solitary confinement for two years for nothing that he has done. Imprisoned without trial when the victim, Dr. Sami al-Arian, is finally taken to court, the jury finds him innocent of all 51 charges leveled against him in the $50m trial, despite the fact that the prosecution flew in 21 Israelis with no connection to trial to testify against him (at the same time, the defense is denied the right to mention the Israeli occupation of Palestine). 'Evidence' included among other inanities a conversations someone had with the defendant in his dream!
Rather than release the man, the state egged on by the Israel Lobby flexes its muscle and threatens to keep him in jail indefinitely unless he agrees to restitution to all those Israelis killed in the Occupied Territories who, as confirmed by the jury, have nothing to do with the al-Arian case. When al-Arian finally agrees to a revised plea-bargain which would allow him to be released and deported for admitting to minor offences. But the judge reneges and imprisons him for another 11 months for refusing to testify at an unrelated case.
The film is brilliantly shot and edited, and presents an intimate portrait of a family living in limbo as they deal with the day-to-day disappointments, frustrations and outrages. They endure in isolation, albeit with exemplary grace and courage, as the heavy handed tactics scare potential allies away. The mainstream media that had lapped up the sensationalism of the earlier 'suspected terrorist' charge seems to have gone AWOL since the process has ultimately turned into an indictment of the US justice system itself. Meanwhile al-Arian languishes in jail.
An up-close encounter with show trials and sham justice in post-911 America. The hope of the film lies in the strength and courage of Sami Al-Arian's family who continue to fight for his rightful release from political imprisonment.
an intimate and kafkaesque indictment of America's sad and haphazard lashing out at pro-Arab activism for fear of terrorism. al-arian is a palestinian intellectual under continued lockdown despite his acquital before a federal grand jury. ginsberg sa... (read more) an intimate and kafkaesque indictment of America's sad and haphazard lashing out at pro-Arab activism for fear of terrorism. al-arian is a palestinian intellectual under continued lockdown despite his acquital before a federal grand jury. ginsberg says there is a lining of objectivity to every radical subjectivity, and so we watch al-arian's persecution principally as it reverberates through his family, the daily struggles of his wife and children. the wcl brought his lawyer to the screening, and he had a chance to debrief us a little, but i've still been sitting with this..
A rather sad indictment of the world we now live in as seen through the trial of outspoken pro-Palestinian Professor Sami Al-Arian. Norwegian director Line Halvorsen's focus on the breakdown of the Al - Arian family provides an emotional and personal... (read more) A rather sad indictment of the world we now live in as seen through the trial of outspoken pro-Palestinian Professor Sami Al-Arian. Norwegian director Line Halvorsen's focus on the breakdown of the Al - Arian family provides an emotional and personal context for exploring an extreme example of some of the consequences suffered by minority families in the US caught in the 9/11 fall-out. A film which at its very heart reflects upon the very limits to which the right to the freedom of speech under the First Amendment has been tested under the current administration. It is bound to get criticised for providing a one sided POV. However Halvorsen wisely chose to stick to the personal angle ensuring at the very least that even if we don't agree on what constitutes an acceptable use of free speech priviliges underthe First that we can at least empathise with what the family was put through.
Pretty good documentary on how the US Government rolled over everything called freedom of speech and the right to a fair trial. A good insight on how it must feel to be an arab in the States today. How can the government get away with stuff like this... (read more) Pretty good documentary on how the US Government rolled over everything called freedom of speech and the right to a fair trial. A good insight on how it must feel to be an arab in the States today. How can the government get away with stuff like this, imprisoning a guy a jury deemed "not guilty"?
A well made and unfuriating documentary about a real life, Kafka-esque legal nightmare.
Try to understand how non American can be angry at USA.
What happened to the good in Christianity? Why must pride destroy the world?s biggest super power?
Critic Reviews
No recent reviews.
Critic ratings and reviews powered by RottenTomatoes.com
Fresh (60% or more critics rated the movie positively)
Rotten (59% or fewer critics rated the movie positively)
All Rotten Tomatoes content is used under license from Rotten Tomatoes. Rotten Tomatoes, Certified Fresh, and the Tomatometer are the trademarks of Incfusion Corporation, d/b/a Rotten Tomatoes, a subsidiary of IGN Entertainment, Inc.
More Like This
No recent suggestions.
Bookmark This App
Make it easy to check out new movies! Click +Bookmark Movies at the bottom of your screen.
- Get Flixster
- iPhone (free!)
- Myspace
- Flixster.com
- iGoogle
- Settings
- Profile Settings
- My Account
- Help



