Memoirs of a Geisha

Reviews (See all 14,937) Write a reviewfor this

It's a hit!

this book touched my heart, it gave me hope that (*spoiler alert*) life can work out

 

 

by Amanda Mayer

No, it's a flop!

Ultimately, didn't like it. The person who lent it to me gave me the impression that it was a very historically authentic sort of memoir. At the ... (show more)

Ultimately, didn't like it. The person who lent it to me gave me the impression that it was a very historically authentic sort of memoir. At the begininning if I'd known that I was reading a historical fiction that took great liberties with major details of geisha life, I might have felt better about the book than I do.

Some will look at a book like this and call it great fiction, and to that, I will heartily agree with them (and wish I'd realized it sooner). Others will accept too much of it as fact, not do any real historical fact-checking, and come away with incorrect (and probably, quite negative) notions of japanese history.

It would have ruined the book to have stamped "this is a work of pure fiction, that takes great liberties with history" on the cover... but I still wish I'd had some clear warning, in that sense. I guess I'm just that gullible. :-) (show less)

 

 

by Aaron Sullivan

More Reviews

• 

  This book has made its way in to my heart and permanently into my mind. I have read my copy so many times that the book no longer stays shut. I cry and laugh and rejoice each time I read it.

   

   

  by Jessica Carver-Skinner on Apr 01, 2008 at 04:30PM

  Already read

  Is this review helpful? yes no
   
• 
  

  I was drawn in by the writing style, but was disappointed with the lack of depth in character development and creativity in plot (chick flick in disguise,) given the intricate history already given to him. Still, I extracted some nice quotes,

  "Hopes are like hair ornaments. Girls want to wear too many of them. When they become old women they look silly wearing even one." p344

  "Adversity is like a strong wind... it holds us back from places we might otherwise go (and) it tears... (show more)

  I was drawn in by the writing style, but was disappointed with the lack of depth in character development and creativity in plot (chick flick in disguise,) given the intricate history already given to him. Still, I extracted some nice quotes,

  "Hopes are like hair ornaments. Girls want to wear too many of them. When they become old women they look silly wearing even one." p344

  "Adversity is like a strong wind... it holds us back from places we might otherwise go (and) it tears away from us all but things that cannot be torn, so that afterward we see ourselves as we really are, and not merely as might like to be." p405

  "How strange... that the same woman who looked me so frankly in the eye as a girl, many years ago, can't bring herself to do it now." p485

  "How curious it is, what the future brings us. You must take care... never to expect too much." p409

  "Sometimes... I think the things I remember are more real than the things I see." p497

  It reminded me of Raise the Red Lantern, a film about a young Chinese girl who becomes one of four wives/concubines in a wealthy man's household. I don't like reading about these young girls who, though clever, have naive hopes of love/romance/friendship/security only to find (at some point) that her life/future is at the mercy of either men who regard her as little more than an object of beauty and pleasure (plaything) or women who regard her with competition instead of sisterhood.

  Some may say that personifying beauty and pleasure (and having such influence) is a respectable/desirable position and it may well be, but I think that power is only an illusion, as the beholder can take his affections away as his attention span pleases. I don't know that it is a feminist or humanist issue - these characters are desperate for love/security and naively think they will attain it from their focus of desire (desperation?). Maybe men and women's ideas of love differ? Maybe it is an individualistic thing? Is the bottom line that desiring a relationship places the source of their happiness external to themselves? Though these films were set some decades ago, isn't it the same now? Aren't we still the same creatures? (show less)

   

   

  by Facebook-gebruiker on Aug 23, 2009 at 03:22PM

  Already read

  Is this review helpful? yes no
   
• See all reviews
  Write a review