This book (or collection rather) reinforced my love of Salinger's work. Absolutely nobody can do dialogue like he can. Each story is based on two o... (show more)
Nine Stories
In the J.D. Salinger benchmark "A Perfect Day for Bananafish," Seymour Glass floats his beach mate Sybil on a raft and tells her about these creatures' tragic flaw. Though they seem normal, if one swims into a hole filled with bananas, it will overeat until it's too fat to escape. Meanwhile, Seymour's wife, Muriel, is back at their Florida hotel, assuring her mother not to worry--Seymour hasn't lost control. Mention of a book he sent her from Germany and several references to his psychiatrist... (show more)
In the J.D. Salinger benchmark "A Perfect Day for Bananafish," Seymour Glass floats his beach mate Sybil on a raft and tells her about these creatures' tragic flaw. Though they seem normal, if one swims into a hole filled with bananas, it will overeat until it's too fat to escape. Meanwhile, Seymour's wife, Muriel, is back at their Florida hotel, assuring her mother not to worry--Seymour hasn't lost control. Mention of a book he sent her from Germany and several references to his psychiatrist lead the reader to believe that World War II has undone him.The war hangs over these wry stories of loss and occasionally unsuppressed rage. Salinger's children are fragile, odd, hypersmart, whereas his grownups (even the materially content) seem beaten down by circumstances--some neurasthenic, others (often female) deeply unsympathetic. The greatest piece in this disturbing book may be "The Laughing Man," which starts out as a man's recollection of the pleasures of storytelling and ends with the intersection between adult need and childish innocence. The narrator remembers how, at nine, he and his fellow Comanches would be picked up each afternoon by the Chief--a Staten Island law student paid to keep them busy. At the end of each day, the Chief winds them down with the saga of a hideously deformed, gentle, world-class criminal. With his stalwart companions, which include "a glib timber wolf" and "a lovable dwarf," the Laughing Man regularly crosses the Paris-China border in order to avoid capture by "the internationally famous detective" Marcel Dufarge and his daughter, "an exquisite girl, though something of a transvestite." The masked hero's luck comes to an end on the same day that things go awry between the Chief and his girlfriend, hardly a coincidence. "A few minutes later, when I stepped out of the Chief's bus, the first thing I chanced to see was a piece of red tissue paper flapping in the wind against the base of a lamppost. It looked like someone's poppy-petal mask. I arrived home with my teeth chattering uncontrollably and was told to go straight to bed." (show less)
Related Media
Photo Gallery
Reviews (See all 882) Write a reviewfor this
It's a hit!
No, it's a flop!
This book (which bears little stylistic resemblance to Catcher in the Rye) contains a couple of decent stories, namely "A Perfect Day for Bananafis... (show more)
This book (which bears little stylistic resemblance to Catcher in the Rye) contains a couple of decent stories, namely "A Perfect Day for Bananafish" and "The Laughing Man," and a lot of mediocre ones that are all more or less the same. Unless you want to invest some real time into picking them apart, the book as a whole probably isn't worth reading. There are also interactions between adults and children that are suspicious at best, and downright scary at worst. (If you happen to have read "Hapworth 16, 1924" by Salinger, the sexual implications are even harder to ignore). (show less)
More Reviews
-
For Esmé (With Love and Squalor) has to be one of the most powerful stories I have ever read. Salinger's work is mindblowing.
Already read
-
I can honestly say that I owe a lot of my growth as a writer to this book of short stories. J.D. Salinger is one of my biggest influences in short stories. I was never very good at them, and I wasn't sure why. Then I read this book and realized that what Salinger excels at is dialogue. In fact, most of these stories are carried on dialogue alone. The actual description is minimal, which not only leaves you to focus on the interaction between the characters, but is impressive beyond belief, si... (show more)
I can honestly say that I owe a lot of my growth as a writer to this book of short stories. J.D. Salinger is one of my biggest influences in short stories. I was never very good at them, and I wasn't sure why. Then I read this book and realized that what Salinger excels at is dialogue. In fact, most of these stories are carried on dialogue alone. The actual description is minimal, which not only leaves you to focus on the interaction between the characters, but is impressive beyond belief, since dialogue is such a difficult thing to write well. I feel that my dialogue is heavily influenced by Salinger's, mainly in this book alone. I highly encourage writers to read this book for examples of brilliant and flawless dialogue, and I encourage readers to read it simply because it's fantastic. Thought-provoking, intelligent, varied and amusing; everything a book of short stories should be. (show less)
Already read
- See all reviews
Conversations
Please log in to join the conversation
-
Favorite Story?
Isn't that a cruel question? I can never pick just one; they're all so marvelous, but I particularly adore The Laughing Man and Uncle Wiggily in CT. I also remember Teddy being just so tragic but perfect. It's been awhile since I've read them, but I still just adore them, along with everything Salinger writes. Thoughts?
Caitlyn Leiter-Mason about 1 year ago
Lists
This book has been added to these lists:
More Stuff
About Us
LivingSocial.com is a social discovery and cataloging network that allows people to review and share their favorite movies, books, games, music, restaurants and beer

Add Bookmark







